Back to the journal

The Warmth Journal

Talk About Addiction Treatment Without a Standoff

Two adults walking and talking on a shaded city footpath, viewed from behind

When a relative is not ready for addiction treatment, the approach with the strongest evidence is calm, non-confrontational and taught to the family rather than aimed at the person using. In controlled trials, families trained to communicate positively and to reward substance-free time got their relatives into treatment far more often than families who used group confrontation.

This article explains what that research found, the communication principles public health agencies recommend, what an assessment involves, and why nobody should be dared to stop drinking abruptly.

Why do so many people refuse treatment?

Refusal is common, not unusual. A review by Meyers, Roozen and Smith notes that a sizeable group of people with substance use disorders refuse treatment, and those who eventually seek it may take 6 to 10 years from first use to do so.

Part of the problem is a narrow picture of what treatment means. The US National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA) points out that most people think of 12-step groups or a 28-day residential stay, when in fact the settings include:

  • Outpatient: regular appointments, in person or online, for counselling, medication or both
  • Intensive outpatient or partial hospitalisation: coordinated non-residential care for more complex needs
  • Residential: a programme in a 24-hour treatment setting
  • Intensive inpatient: medically directed 24-hour care, which can manage withdrawal

Knowing the range changes the first conversation. It does not have to start with “will you go to rehab?” The first step can simply be an assessment.

What does research say gets people into treatment?

The best-supported approach is CRAFT (Community Reinforcement and Family Training). A therapist works with the family member, not the person using substances, with the aim of helping a relative who refuses treatment to accept it.

A systematic review by Roozen and colleagues, published in Addiction in 2010, pooled four high-quality randomised trials involving 264 family members. It found that:

  • CRAFT led to treatment engagement about three times as often as Al-Anon/Nar-Anon family groups
  • CRAFT was roughly twice as effective as the Johnson Institute intervention, in which family members gather to confront the person and press them to enter treatment
  • about two-thirds of relatives who had refused treatment went on to attend, typically after the family member had four to six CRAFT sessions
  • family members’ own psychological and physical health improved markedly whichever of the three approaches they received

These are research averages from studies outside Thailand. They do not predict what will happen in any one family, and CRAFT is delivered by trained therapists. It is not a script to copy from an article.

Which communication principles can families use now?

Meyers and colleagues stress that CRAFT does not pressure the person into treatment. It works gently through the family. Its main principles are:

  • Reward substance-free time. Share activities the person enjoys when they are not using, and step away politely when they start.
  • Be consistent. Apply this across many behaviours, not occasionally.
  • Use positive communication throughout. Say what you would like to happen, without blame or sarcasm.
  • Know the difference between rewarding sobriety and enabling. Enabling means a family member unintentionally reinforcing drinking or drug use.
  • Assess the risk of violence first. CRAFT therapists discuss the potential for domestic violence before any plan is made.

The US Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) recommends open-ended questions, meaning questions that invite an explanation rather than a yes or no. The CDC recommends listening without judgement. Both help you learn what actually worries the person, whether that is work, cost or privacy.

Timing matters too. Talk when the person is not intoxicated and you have privacy. NIAAA notes that alcohol clouds judgement, which makes an intoxicated moment a poor time for a decision.

What happens at an assessment?

An assessment is a meeting with a doctor or specialist who asks about substance use, health and circumstances, and examines the person where needed. The aim is to judge how serious the problem is, what the risks are and which kind of care fits. Attending an assessment does not commit anyone to a residential stay.

For alcohol, NIAAA lists the 11 symptoms clinicians use to identify alcohol use disorder, asking about the past year:

  • drinking more, or for longer, than intended
  • wanting to cut down or stop more than once, but not managing it
  • spending a lot of time drinking or recovering from it
  • craving a drink so strongly that it is hard to think of anything else
  • drinking that interferes with home, family, work or study
  • carrying on drinking despite trouble with family or friends
  • giving up important or enjoyable activities in order to drink
  • more than once ending up in situations that raised the risk of injury, such as driving, swimming or using machinery
  • drinking despite feeling depressed or anxious, worsening another health problem, or after a memory blackout
  • needing much more alcohol for the same effect
  • withdrawal symptoms as the alcohol wears off, such as poor sleep, shakiness, restlessness, nausea, sweating or a racing heart

Two or more symptoms indicate alcohol use disorder: two to three is mild, four to five moderate, six or more severe. NIAAA also states that the condition is a common medical condition, not a choice or a character flaw, and that most people who have it recover or improve markedly.

NIAAA suggests asking a provider these questions:

  • What kinds of treatment do you offer, and do you provide medication and address mental health at the same time?
  • Is treatment tailored to the individual?
  • What will be expected of the person in treatment?
  • Do you measure treatment success, and how?
  • How do you handle a return to drinking?

Our treatment options page describes the care pathway at The Warmth Rehab.

Why should nobody stop drinking suddenly to prove a point?

Someone who is dependent on alcohol has a body that has adapted to needing it in order to function normally. Stopping abruptly can trigger dangerous withdrawal. According to the NHS, symptoms begin 6 to 12 hours after the last drink and usually last 3 to 7 days. They include anxiety, poor sleep, nausea and vomiting, a racing heartbeat, sweating, shaking, hallucinations, confusion and seizures.

The NHS advises getting medical help before stopping, and going to an emergency department for severe withdrawal: visible shaking, unusual restlessness or irritability, confusion such as not knowing what day it is, seeing or hearing things that are not there, or a seizure. Doctors can prescribe medication that makes withdrawal safer and less distressing. At The Warmth Rehab, medical detox is doctor-led and monitored, with medication support where appropriate.

Overdose is a separate emergency. If someone is unconscious, cannot be woken, is breathing slowly or irregularly, or has a seizure, call emergency services at once without waiting for every sign. NIAAA’s full list of overdose signs is worth knowing before you need it.

What can families do if the answer is still no?

One refusal does not end the process. In the trials Roozen reviewed, results came from several sessions over time, not from one conversation. In the meantime:

  • Pause when it turns into an argument, and return to the subject when both of you are calm.
  • Avoid threats you do not intend to carry out, and do not confiscate documents, lock doors or try to take someone to treatment by force. These raise the risk of violence.
  • Look after your own health. NIAAA advises relatives who develop depression or anxiety to seek professional help.
  • Get advice for yourself. In Thailand, the 1165 drug treatment helpline is free and open 24 hours, and families can call even when the person using substances refuses help. Elsewhere, a family doctor or local addiction service can advise.

If there are threats or violence, get to a safe place before anything else and call for help.

The Warmth Rehab’s family programme runs alongside the client’s own treatment. You can contact the team to ask about a first appointment.

Accreditations & partners

Trusted standards and partnerships

The Warmth Rehab is certified by Thailand Ministry of Public Health, recognised under SHA Plus, and a partner of Recovery.com and Thailand Recovery.

Seal of the Ministry of Public Health of Thailand SHA Plus certification mark from Amazing Thailand Safety and Health Administration
Partners
Call Us Chat with Us